They want to sign a letter of intent. It is explicitly non-binding, it names a number you are pleased with, and it asks for ninety days of exclusivity while they complete diligence.
Everyone treats it as progress. They have bought ninety days of your life and a first claim on your company for the cost of a signature that obliges them to nothing.
Why these three models
The decision is whether to sign a non-binding letter, and what to change in it if you do. The features that fire are a commitment that costs one side nothing to make, an option granted at no price whose value rises with your own uncertainty, and a document that sets the sequence and the reference for everything that follows.
Three lenses. Certification produces an equilibrium answer about what a costless signature attests. Option value produces a random answer about what you are handing over. Path dependence produces a cycle answer about how the letter shapes the negotiation you have not had yet. The third is the one that surprises people, because it operates months later and looks like an unrelated disagreement.
1. What does a costless signature certify
Start with what the document costs each party to sign, because that is what determines what it attests.
For them: nothing enforceable. They may walk at any point, for any reason or none, and in most versions the only real obligations are confidentiality and the exclusivity you granted. Their signature is a statement of current interest by someone who can revise it freely.
A claim carries information in proportion to what it would cost to make falsely.1 A non-binding letter is close to free, which means it separates a serious counterparty from an idle one hardly at all. Some of the most enthusiastic letters come from parties who wanted the exclusivity, the diligence access, or simply the option.
Which does not mean refuse. It means look for the parts that are costly and insist those be the binding ones. A break fee, however small, changes the arithmetic of walking away. A diligence budget they have committed to spend. Named individuals with dated availability. Board or investment-committee approval already obtained rather than described as a formality. Each of those is expensive to the extent that they are not serious, which is exactly what makes them informative.
The single most useful question is what internal approval has already happened. A letter signed after committee approval and a letter signed before it are the same document and completely different objects, and the answer is freely given.
The approval question needs a checkable form or it collects a reassurance. Ask which body approves this, when it last sat, and whether this transaction was on that agenda. Three specifics, all easily supplied by a party who has been through the process and all vague from a party who has not. Then ask for the letter to name the remaining approvals and their dates. A counterparty willing to write down that their investment committee meets on the fourteenth of next month has just told you what your ninety days are actually for.
Expect the break fee to be refused, and treat the refusal as an answer rather than as the end. Very few early-stage letters carry one. What is available instead is smaller and still costly to them: a capped reimbursement of your legal and accounting fees if they withdraw without a diligence finding, a deposit held by their lawyer, or an exclusivity that shortens automatically each time they miss a milestone. Ask for the fee, accept one of the three, and note which one they take. A party that will accept none of them has told you the signature is all they intend to spend.
2. You are granting an option and getting nothing for it
The second lens prices what you handed over, which is the part the number at the top distracts from.
Exclusivity gives them the right to proceed and no obligation to. That is an option, and options are worth more the more uncertain the underlying is and the longer they run.2 Your business is uncertain and the period is ninety days, so what you granted is worth a great deal to them and you charged nothing for it.
Meanwhile the premium you are paying is not abstract. During exclusivity you cannot talk to anyone else, which means any alternative process stops. Alternatives decay when they are not maintained: the other party moves on, their interest cools, their own circumstances change. If this deal fails at day eighty-five, you do not return to where you were at day one, you return somewhere worse.
Exclusivity is not a pause. It is the systematic destruction of your alternatives, paid for by you.
The instruments are ordinary and are almost always available if raised early. Shorten the period, because ninety days is a convention rather than a requirement and forty-five is common. Tie the exclusivity to milestones so that it lapses automatically if diligence has not started by a named date. Carve out the right to continue conversations you had already begun. And make the clock start on the delivery of the diligence list, not on signature, so that a slow start does not consume your period.
When they insist on ninety days, split it rather than argue about the number. Forty-five days, extending by thirty if the diligence list has been delivered and their outstanding requests are current at day forty. That gives a serious buyer everything they need and a slow one nothing, and it is easier to agree than a flat reduction because neither side has to concede that ninety was unreasonable.
Price the delays that are structural rather than behavioural, because they consume your period without anybody being at fault. A buyer funding from offshore may need central bank clearance, a tax clearance certificate, or a source-of-funds confirmation their own bank takes weeks to issue. Ask early which of those apply and put them on the milestone schedule with dates against them. A period spent waiting for a regulator is still a period in which your alternatives decay, and it is the most common reason a forty-five day exclusivity becomes four months anyway.
All four are refused after signature and granted before it, which is the general shape of everything in this article.
3. The letter writes the negotiation that follows
The third lens is about what happens in month three, and it is why the document matters even though nothing in it is enforceable.
Everything in the final agreement will be negotiated from the letter rather than from first principles. Anything you conceded there is the starting point. Anything left vague is resolved later, under time pressure, by whoever has more leverage, which by then is them. And the sequence itself accumulates: each agreed clause raises the cost of reopening earlier ones, so the order in which things are settled quietly determines the outcome.3
The specific pattern to expect is a reduction. Diligence surfaces something, the number moves down, and the argument you are now having is about a discount from their headline rather than about what the business is worth. That is not necessarily bad faith; it is what a non-binding number is for.
The headline number does a particular kind of work here that is easy to miss. Once it exists in writing, every later conversation is measured against it, so a reduction feels like a discount from a real price rather than a fresh assessment of the business.4 The number in the letter is not a price, it is the reference the real price will be argued down from.
So the defences are structural. Put the deal-shaping terms in the letter even though it is non-binding: the treatment of your key people, what happens to the option pool, escrow and its duration, any earn-out and how it is measured. Those are the terms that are cheap to agree now and expensive to introduce later, and their absence from the letter is not neutral, it is a concession you have not noticed making.
There is a defence against the reduction that is cheap to install and rarely requested. Express the number as a formula on a stated metric rather than as a figure: a multiple of the trailing twelve months of a defined revenue line, with the definition written out. A diligence finding then changes an input both sides can check rather than opening an argument about what the business is worth. It converts the conversation you are dreading into arithmetic, and arithmetic is much harder to conduct in bad faith.
Add one sentence about how a change gets proposed. Any revision to the headline will be accompanied by the specific finding that caused it and its quantified effect. That sentence binds nobody, and it does not need to. It sets the form of the month-three conversation, which is precisely what this section says a letter does. A buyer who will not write it intends to revise the number for a reason they would rather not have to name.
And write down, before signing, the number below which you walk. Not to disclose it, but because it will be much harder to identify in month three, when you have spent four months and everyone is tired and the alternatives you had at the start have quietly gone.
What the three say together
- Ask what internal approval has already happened. Before or after committee is the whole difference.
- Make the costly parts binding: a break fee, a committed diligence budget, named people with dates.
- Shorten the exclusivity, start the clock on the diligence list rather than on signature, and make it lapse if milestones slip.
- Put the deal-shaping terms in the letter, and write your walk-away number down before you sign it.
Where they disagree
The certification argument and the path argument disagree about how much to put in the letter.
Certification says keep it thin and make the few real terms binding, because a long non-binding document is a long list of things that cost nothing to agree, and negotiating it hard spends goodwill on language that will not be enforced.
Path dependence says make it thick, because every term absent from the letter is settled later under worse conditions, and the effort spent now is the cheapest it will ever be. A thin letter is not neutral; it is a decision to negotiate everything from a weaker position.
The reconciliation is to sort the terms by when they get harder rather than by whether they bind. Terms about the shape of the deal, meaning people, pool, escrow, earn-out and structure, go in the letter, because they become expensive to raise later. Terms about process and price detail can stay out, because they will be negotiated properly anyway and putting them in only creates an anchor. Founders usually do the reverse, negotiating the headline number hard and leaving the shape to the lawyers, which is a decision about where the value goes.
What none of them contain
None of the three prices what the process does to your company while it runs. Four months of diligence consumes the founder, the finance lead and often the best engineer, and the business is being valued on numbers produced during exactly the period nobody was running it.
None of them handles the counterparty who is a customer or a partner as well. A failed acquisition conversation leaves a commercial relationship in place with a party who now knows everything, and the models here treat the negotiation as though it ends when it ends.
None of them prices the information you hand over during diligence. A counterparty who walks at day eighty-five leaves with your cohort data, your margins, your pipeline and your key-person map, and in the case where they are also a potential competitor that transfer is the most valuable thing in the process. The staged data room is the ordinary defence and it has to be designed before the letter, not requested after it.
And one property the ensemble will not produce: your team will find out. Long exclusivity periods leak, through lawyers, through data-room access, through the founder’s calendar, and a team that half-knows an acquisition is being discussed behaves differently for four months whatever anyone announces.
The one action that survives the ignorance: before signing, write the number below which you walk away and put it somewhere you will read it in month three. Everything else in this article is negotiable and that number is the one thing you will not be able to establish later, because by then you will have spent four months earning it.
Who has to move
The founder, at the letter rather than at the definitive agreement, because every protection in this article is cheap to request now and refused later. The instinct is to treat a non-binding document as a formality and save the negotiating capital for the real one, which hands over the exclusivity and the anchors for free. The cheapest first test is the approval question, asked in the next call: has this been through committee, or is that still ahead. The answer takes ten seconds and it changes what the letter is.
Sources and notes
- Jeffrey Carpenter and Andrea Robbett, Game Theory and Behavior, MIT Press. Costly signalling and certification, and the result that a claim separates types only in proportion to what it would cost to make falsely, are developed in the chapters on signalling and asymmetric information. Used in section 1, including the corollary that the informative parts of a non-binding document are the few provisions that impose a real cost on the party offering them.
- Sanjit S. Dhami, The Foundations of Behavioral Economic Analysis, Oxford University Press, and the options literature it references. The value of a right held without obligation rises with the uncertainty of the underlying and with the length of the period. Used in section 2. No option value is computed; the argument requires only that the value be positive, substantial and uncompensated, which follows from the structure.
- Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel and Peter Klimek, Introduction to the Theory of Complex Systems, Oxford University Press. Path dependence, in which the order of events determines which configuration is reached and each step raises the cost of moving away from it, is developed in the chapters on evolutionary processes. Used in section 3 for the claim that the sequence of agreed terms shapes the final agreement independently of what any of them bind.
- Sanjit S. Dhami, The Foundations of Behavioral Economic Analysis, Oxford University Press. Reference dependence, under which a figure is evaluated against a comparison point rather than in absolute terms, explains why a headline number in a non-binding letter continues to govern the negotiation after diligence: the later discussion is conducted as a discount from that number rather than as a fresh assessment. Direction only; no magnitude claimed.
A note on a number this article does not give. There is no standard exclusivity period, despite ninety days being quoted as though there were. It is a convention imported from larger transactions and it is negotiable in both directions. Ask what they need it for, and you will usually find the answer describes a shorter period than the one they asked for.
Joshua Agonya Pi’Rwot, Founder.